We explore properties of the Berezin range $B(C_\phi)$ of a composition operator $C_\phi$ on the Hardy space $H^2$, including constraints on its location in the complex plane $\mathbb{C}$, topological properties, shape, symmetry, and convexity. For example, we show that$B(C_\phi) \subseteq \{z\in \mathbb{C}: \Re(z) > 0 \ \text{and}\ |z| \le 1 + |\phi(0)|\},$ that $B(C_\phi)$ is closed if and only if $C_\phi$ is the identity operator, and that $B(C_\phi)$ contains all its boundary points except for $0$ if $C_\phi$ is compact. Addressing questions raised by Cowen and Felder, we show that $C_\phi$ can be a (nondegenerate) disk and characterize when $B(C_\phi)$ is convex if $\phi$ is linear.